← Back to podcast
The Current

ACA Compliance 10 Years In: Equifax on Why "No News" Isn't Good News

Transcript

[00:00]

Todd Hurst: Don't think that just because you checked a box in January or February that it's done. You have to know what is getting into the IRS's hands because they could eventually come calling.

-----------------

Ansel Parikh: Welcome to another episode of The Current, a bi-monthly podcast exploring the intersection of people, finance, and data. I'm Ansel Parikh, co-founder of Finch, the connectivity platform for the employment ecosystem. And today I'm joined by Todd Hurst, who leads ACA Business Development at Equifax Workforce Solutions, home of ACA HQ, the platform thousands of employers rely on for their 1094 and 1095 reporting. Todd has spent more than 20 years in the healthcare and benefits world, gaining experience across benefits administration, product, compliance, and now business development, which he uses today to help employers navigate the Affordable Care Act.

Todd, welcome to the show.

Todd: Thank you. Thanks for having me, Ansel. I appreciate it.

‍Ansel: Yeah. So, we mentioned 20 years in and around healthcare and benefits. And again, you started on the administration side, and now you're in business development. Of all the corners of this industry you could have planted a flag in, you ended up specializing in the ACA. What drew you to that, and what's kept you there?

Todd: Great question. I like to joke that it was necessity, but really it's the Affordable Care Act when it came out, where the employer mandate came out, and it was just very interesting to me, oddly enough to say that a regulatory piece is interesting. But the whole focus around employers managing their workforce against these regulations that allow employees to get affordable benefits, or just benefits in general. Let's just leave it at that, right? Let's just leave "affordable" out of the subject here. It's enabling employees that normally wouldn't get benefits to get benefits. And so while it created this burden for the employer, it also helped the employer with saving costs while also offering benefits to employees that normally wouldn't have them.

So when it first came out, it was this very interesting thing that was new and frustrating to some, but also this new thing that, okay, we have to do this, and so let's make sure that we do it right. And so that really drew my attention to making sure that, whatever capacity I had in it, whether account management or product development or sales or whatever it was, the employers were doing it right. And then as you learn about the complexities of it, just having that SME capacity started to really get me drawn in, like, okay, we could make sure that as an organization we're doing this better and better and better so that it's easier and easier and easier for clients.

‍Ansel: Yeah. And it's wild, because it's been over 10 years since that mandate took effect. I think it was back in 2015. So you've essentially had a front-row seat to the entire lifecycle of ACA compliance as employers have lived it. And so maybe when you think back over those 10 years to the first reporting seasons versus today, what's the single biggest way the employer conversation has changed?

[03:21]

Todd: Yeah, over the last 10 years, employers have gone on their own and learned it. When I think back to 2015, 2016, it's probably those first few years. We started to see employers asking for this in 2014. And I remember employers coming and going, "We don't know what we're doing. We need you to do this, just do it. Here's access to our data. Just go do what you need to do."

Now we come into calendar year '26, and we're already planning, thinking about what Q1 of 2027 is going to look like. Employers are more savvy now. They understand the regulation. They are able to do a little bit of pre-work, and they know what they need and they know what they want. Before, it was just that they knew what they needed. They needed to check this box and file to the IRS by X date, and these forms had to go out to their employees by Y date. Now they can sit there and go, okay, we have employees in these states, so we know that we also have to do state reporting. Or we offer benefits this way to our employees, and so it should be a little easier. We know we don't need as much payroll interaction with our vendor. So it's definitely evolved in how employers are looking at the regulations and at the end-of-year process in the last 10 years. So that to me has probably been the most interesting.

But if I may tag on to the end of that: the workforce is evolving, and also there's a generational shift. And so you're having folks come into the HR space that are new to the workforce, that maybe have never heard of the ACA before. And so we're starting to see that cyclical process where there are times where we're almost going back to 2015, and an employer's coming to us going, "I just came into this role. I don't know what this is. I just know someone was doing it, and I want you to take it off my plate." So, it's interesting.

Ansel: Well, that makes me feel a little bit old. But it makes a lot of sense. You have to go back into educating people again about what the requirements are. And I think in previous talks or webinars you've done, you've talked a little bit about how employers seem to also be either relaxing their focus or shifting their benefits offerings to make ACA easier, but it's not actually easier, and it's not like the IRS has forgotten about it. So maybe could you dig into that a little bit more? Where are you seeing this complacency showing up most?

[06:07]

Todd: I think you hit it when you talk about employers changing how they're managing their benefits. Employers are shifting how they're offering benefits, what they're offering, when they're offering it. That makes the ACA appear to be easier. And that's a great point that you bring up, that it's not easier, but there is a bit of complacency in there of, okay, I'm offering the entire workforce benefits as of 25 hours, or if you work for us an hour a week, you're getting offered benefits. That makes the Affordable Care Act regulatory management throughout the year easier, because you don't have to go, okay, who's averaging 30 hours? Who's not? Who do I need to offer to this month? Who don't I need to offer to? However, at the end of the year, you still have to have accurate forms.

And so there's still some complexity at the end that I think employers are forgetting about. And the IRS does a good job at allowing them to forget about it until it's time to not forget about it. So the IRS is behind. We know this. They're sending notifications out right now for tax year 2023, and failure-to-file notifications for tax year 2024. I just mentioned earlier we're already heading into tax year 2026 preparedness for Q1 of '27. So the IRS is giving a little bit of a comfort zone, but then there's the risk that they're going to come calling, knocking at the door.

And so, whether they leverage Equifax and our team to support them with their ACA or not, I urge employers to just keep your finger on the pulse, keep your foot on the gas. And don't forget about this, and don't think that just because you checked a box in January or February that it's done. You still have to know what's going on with the regulations, you have to know what's coming down the pipeline with any changes, and you have to know what is getting into the IRS's hands, because they could eventually come calling.

Ansel: I think it's definitely a key point, that feeling that there might be less enforcement. And I know there have been recent laws, I think at the end of 2024, the Paperwork Burden Reduction Act and, I think, the Employer Reporting Improvement Act. These are really catchy names. They really reduced some of the load of sending physical notices to employees, or gave more time to respond to those IRS notices. But I'm wondering, do you think that kind of plays into this feeling of, well, now there's less paperwork, I'm getting a little more wiggle room? It kind of feeds into this, not complacency, but more of "the enforcement's going to slow down," especially when you add the IRS being backlogged already.

Todd: Yeah, it adds into the "well, if we haven't heard yet, we're not going to hear from them." And I do think that those two acts that were passed at the end of December, sneakily, might I add, Christmas Day notification-type things... But adding those in, they help employers. I do think there are some employers that go, "Great, we don't have to send these out anymore. Fantastic." Well, you still have to have them ready. You still have to notify your employees how they can get them if they want them.

The other piece of it is that the enforcement of the penalties is probably not there in the eyes of the employer, because if you turn on the news, you're not hearing about penalty enforcement under the Affordable Care Act. If you're looking to find out what the IRS is really doing, you should talk to an SME within the ACA space, talk to your legal team, understand what they've heard, because there is enforcement. The letters are still coming out, and the IRS is holding employers accountable. It's just that you're very rarely going to hear about it, because no one wants that to be public knowledge, I think, from an employer space, and the IRS doesn't make it public knowledge.

Ansel: Yeah, exactly. Compliance isn't something that you think about as an employer as a proactive thing, but I think the fines, depending on the penalty, have gone up to $3,000 to $5,000 per employee in 2026. So it's not like it's getting cheaper to make those mistakes. I guess for you, then, from your seat, where do you see the biggest exposure risks today? Is it misclassifying employees, botching affordability, missing dependent information? Curious how you see that playing out.

[10:23]

Todd: That's a fantastic question. I view it as not having visibility into what you're sending over to the IRS, so inaccurate or incomplete Forms 1095 or even Forms 1094. We've seen a lot where we've had some clients come to us that have 4980H(a) penalties in the multimillion-dollar levels because the vendor that they were using didn't check a box on the 1094. And it's just that one simple miss that, as an employer, you're not really thinking about. But then you get this letter and you go, okay, great, now I have to explain this. And yeah, the penalty gets abated, but that's time and resources that you have to put in to look at that form and figure out why you received that penalty. So I think it just goes back to, again, the penalties are increasing.

So employers, you have to make sure that your forms are accurate. You have to make sure they're filed timely, really, to the federal, to the states. And make sure that what is on that form is really lining up with what's in your benefits administration system. Did you really offer that person? Can you back that offer up? Can you show the documentation? That's very key. So it's really just making sure that the data that you're sending over to the IRS is showing the true movement and the true story of your employee. Because anytime something comes into doubt, whether it be through affordability or movement or offers, if you don't have that documentation to show that, then you're going to be at risk of a potential penalty.

‍Ansel: There's definitely a lot to keep track of. And I think that's why people look for solutions. But I actually want to call back a little bit to something we talked about briefly earlier in this conversation, which was around employers also trying to shift their benefit strategy over the last 10 years. One of these offerings that is getting pretty hot right now, that people are talking about, is ICHRAs, and really having this shift from group-type benefits to sending people to the individual market with a defined contribution. So I guess, what do you think of the strategy, and where do you see ICHRAs going in the next three to five years?

Todd: I'm good with the strategy. I think it's great. And if it works for an employer, fantastic. There are complexities that come with all these things. And ICHRA, it's not new. And I think it is back to what I talked about with retention. Employees want... it's more than just medical, dental, vision, but also it's about the cost of it. And so when we bring that affordability concept into overall medical benefits, the power of an ICHRA is that you're able to basically give your employees that power to go pick what they want, what works for them, what works for their family.

And so that's where an ICHRA comes into play. And a lot of focus right now is on smaller organizations, which makes sense, but I think in the next two to three years, as it starts to take off and employers hear what their employees are saying around the cost of benefits and access to benefits and whatnot, I think we're going to see ICHRA start to take off a little bit. And we've even seen it in the federal spotlight as well, where there's the idea of just giving employees money to go find their own healthcare insurance. It's not as simple as that, but I think that it's a great strategy. It's going to work for some, it's not going to work for others. I've talked to a lot of employers, and a lot of employees even, that have said, "I want nothing. I love my group health plan, I love the access that I have, I love the doctors, et cetera. Let's just stick with it."

That makes total sense. And so I think now having two options for employers to look at is great, and it's going to change healthcare a little bit, and we're going to see it, I think, sway. We'll see the pendulum move a little bit over the next three to five years as this starts to take off and grow.

[14:18]

Ansel: I think the employees of tomorrow are really thinking about the whole package of employment. Not just how much do I make, but all the other pieces. And I think the financial literacy, as well as even the healthcare literacy, is improving, even though it's still an uphill battle. It's a lot of acronyms and confusing terminology, but at the end of the day, this is increasingly the thing that is necessary to understand if you want to have a successful life.

I know you talk to a lot of employers, and this is really the heart of what I wanted to get into: if you had every benefits leader and CFO in a room, what are the one or two things they are not thinking about today that you're confident they should be?

Todd: I think the one thing that they're not thinking about is probably just the compliance awareness, because I was in a conversation not too long ago with several folks where someone said, "I don't really work in that." Someone senior level said, "I don't really work in that. I've got a team that manages that. I haven't heard anything. It must be going great." That to me is the one thing that, if I were able to sit down with everyone, I would say: don't have that mentality.

It probably makes the days go easier, probably allows you to focus more on strategic planning and what you're going to do in the next three, five years with your benefits offering and how the organization is growing. I get that. I would at least have a conversation with your team once a week, maybe once a month, to understand where the team is and where the organization is from a compliance standpoint. And not just under ACA regulations, all other compliance aspects. Being compliant is going to save a lot of headaches down the road. And so I think that would be my number one piece of advice: don't let your answer be, "I haven't heard from them, so it must be going great." I would recommend not going about it that way.

Ansel: Yeah. I feel that sets you up for a potential surprise down the line. And everybody loves compliance surprises. So it's definitely a dangerous thing to have from a mindset standpoint, because all it takes is one error, one checkbox missed, and all of a sudden you've got penalties coming back, and who are they going to blame but the person who wasn't paying attention to the details? So it's a thankless job, that's for sure, but it is necessary.

Todd: And the other piece of that too is, again, specific to ACA, the data that's being sent to the IRS. There's an address, there's a name on those returns, and that's who the IRS corresponds with. Those could end up in a mailroom, and then no one's seeing them for 30, 60, 90 days. And so that's the other thing: if you're going, "I haven't heard anything, so it's great. Everything must be going good," there could be a letter that's sitting there that you haven't responded to. And the longer it sits there, the harder it is to go to the IRS and go, "No, yeah, we messed up, but we'll fix it, we'll get it done. Everything's good. Here's our data, here's our response." At some point the IRS is going to go, "Well, we don't want to hear it. We told you, you didn't respond to us. So here are the consequences of that."

I would just, again, compare it to when kids are playing in a room and it goes real quiet over the house. Just because you're not hearing anything doesn't mean it's going great. So definitely keep a pulse on everything that's going on within the organization.

[17:57]

Ansel: I also liked how you framed it a little bit as a data problem as well, 'cause it's almost like a daisy chain of different systems, as well as reporting and filing, all the way through to the IRS. Is there any piece of that chain that you think is particularly weak, or that would just be helpful for employers to pay attention to more, so that whatever they can control is done in a way that's as efficient and accurate as possible?

Todd: Well, that's a great point right there. It becomes an entire person's job. That right there is a challenge, and really something that I would recommend employers avoid. Don't have that single-threaded resource to manage this compliance aspect. But also know where things are going. Make sure you have a pulse on where your data is going. Make sure you have a pulse on what that data looks like, the quality of that data, and make sure that if you are notified of a question or an inquiry from the IRS, or really anything of a compliance nature, if there's ever a question, you know who's getting that question and what they're doing with it.

We've worked with employers where letters get shoved in a drawer, no one knows about them, and that person leaves the organization, someone finds them, and then you're going, okay, I now have to work through all of this and correct all of this. And yeah, even though the IRS might be slow in communication, they never give up. We'll give them that. They are resilient.

Ansel: Yeah, definitely one place you can't avoid is the IRS. Well, I really appreciate you taking the time. To sum everything up, we've talked about the evolution of ACA from the beginning to where it is now; this generational shift that's happening that almost takes you back in time to go, all right, we've got to re-educate this whole new generation of people, leaders, and executives on what this means and how to stay compliant. And then on top of all of it, there's this whole shift in how benefits are administered, how the strategy has shifted to really make sure you're compliant, but also to create choice and options for employees.

And so these are a lot of shifts in the last 10 years, and I'm sure the next 10 will also be very intense. So how do you think these shifts will change what your job looks like, say, in the next five years?

[20:13]

Todd: I get this question, or a form of this question, a lot. And generally it comes in the form of, what happens when the ACA goes away? So that's where everyone's focus tends to be. But when is the ACA going to go away? And my response is the same every time. It's really a question back to the employer: do you want it to go away at the federal level? Because what we saw back in 2019 and 2020 was when the employer mandate was removed, you had states implement it. So Massachusetts was the original birthplace of the Affordable Care Act, and they got rid of their employee mandate back in 2015, 2016. And then they brought it back in 2019, 2020, when the employee mandate was removed at the federal level. Then we saw California, New Jersey, Rhode Island, and DC jump on board.

And so where I see it in the next five years is the employer mandate will continue to evolve at the federal level. We're going to see more things similar to the Paperwork Burden Reduction Act come into play, where reporting is not going to be as extensive, yet you're still going to have to report something. So we'll still see that, but if it goes away at the federal level, you're going to see states go, "We can take advantage of this," and they're going to enact their own Affordable Care Act mandate, whether at the employer and employee level or just the employer level. And they'll start enforcing those rules pretty heavily, because it can be an advantage to them.

So I always ask anyone that asks me this, "Where is this going to be in five years? When is the ACA going to go away? What are you going to do?" My question is always, do you want to deal with just the federal? Or do you want to deal with 15, 20, 30, 50 states having their own regulation in place, that they have the right to have different in every state? So it'll be interesting to see where it goes. I think it's going to continue to evolve. We've seen success at the federal marketplace with Affordable Care Act plans, which translates into the employer and employee mandate. So as we continue to see that, we'll just see this thing evolve. And I'm looking forward to it. I like the challenge, and it keeps us all on our toes. So, excited.

Ansel: It sounds like you'll still be busy no matter what happens here. But it's exciting to see how that changes, and I'm really excited to follow you as you help lead the charge on how employers need to adjust their processes as well as their strategy to make sure they stay compliant and can run their businesses and their workforces effectively. So Todd, thank you so much for sharing all the detail and history. Really appreciate you taking the time.

Todd: Yeah, thank you very much. Glad I could be a part of it, and just looking forward to what the future brings us.

Show notes

New laws cut back on ACA paperwork, and the IRS is running two years behind. Together, they're a perfect storm for employer complacency — but the penalty letters are still coming.

In this episode of The Current, Finch co-founder Ansel Parikh sits down with Todd Hurst, who leads ACA business development at Equifax Workforce Solutions, to look at what a decade of filing ACA reporting for thousands of employers has taught him. 

Todd explains why lighter reporting rules and a backlogged IRS are making customers complacent, and why the biggest exposure usually traces back to the employment data behind Forms 1094 and 1095: what was offered, to whom, and whether the records can prove it. 

For anyone building or running benefits, HR, or compliance services, you'll walk away with a provider's view of where ACA risk is hiding, why the customers who think the job is done are the ones to watch, and how ICHRAs and state mandates could reshape the work ahead.

Listen to this episode to learn:

  • How one unchecked box on a vendor-filed 1094 led to a multimillion-dollar penalty
  • Why lighter reporting rules and a backlogged IRS are a perfect storm for customer complacency
  • Where the data behind ACA filings breaks down before it ever reaches the IRS
  • What the rise of ICHRAs means for the platforms that support benefits and compliance
  • How the end of the ACA could lead to more regulatory complexity 

Meet the expert

Todd Hurst
Head of ACA Sales, Equifax Workforce Solutions

Todd Hurst leads ACA business development at Equifax Workforce Solutions, home of ACA HQ, which thousands of employers rely on for their Forms 1094 and 1095 reporting. Over more than 20 years in healthcare and benefits — spanning benefits administration, product development, account management, and sales at companies including Optum, Businessolver, and Health e(fx) — he's had a front-row seat to ACA compliance since its very first reporting season. Today he helps employers keep their filings accurate and make sure IRS letters land with someone who's watching.

About The Current

The Current is a bi-monthly podcast that explores the intersection of people, finance, and data, featuring conversations with the operators, builders, and leaders shaping the employment ecosystem.

About the host

Ansel Parikh
Co-founder & COO, Finch

Ansel Parikh is the co-founder and COO of Finch, the leading API platform for payroll, HR, and benefits connectivity. He’s spent the last six years building the infrastructure that enables secure, permissioned access to HR and payroll data for a broad ecosystem of software companies serving employers, employees, and service providers.